I think the best bourbon bar in Muncie, Indiana is Trust Your Butcher Steakhouse. And let me explain why I think that is the case.

When you think of Muncie, Indiana, you most likely think of David Letterman and the lovely Ball State University (also known as the Harvard of Muncie). Some of you might wonder where the heck is Muncie in the first place. Other might think of the lovely trains and pot holes that make the city feel like home.

When I think of Muncie, Indiana, I think of my favorite places to go for dinner and a drink. Growing up in the New Castle area, Muncie was (and still is) our big town. Having gone to college at Ball State, I have grown to love the city of Muncie and the restaurants and bars that make it feel like home. I’ve been going to Savage’s Ale House since I turned 21 years old. I’m probably the biggest cheerleader for The Guardian Brewing Company (keep it up Bill and Jason). And I’ll soon have my name on the bar of the Heorot, one of the best craft beer bars in the world.

When it comes to bourbon, Muncie isn’t the most exciting city for those who don’t know where to look. As a quasi-local, I have tried about every place in town and I know where you need to go to get some good food and have a pretty awesome bourbon selection.

My all-time favorite place to grab a bourbon was at the Neely House until it closed out of the blue about a year ago. Cam (the mixologist) was curating an amazing bourbon list and always had new things for me to try. Once the Neely House closed, I had to take my bourbon hunting somewhere else. And it led me to my local butcher shop…

You read that right. My hunt for the best bourbon bar in Muncie has its origins in a meat market. Lahody’s Meats to be exact. I’ve been getting my steaks, smoked pork chops, and everything else from Lahody’s since 2011. I’ve masted the art of grilling the perfect medium rare filet and I know you always ask for the dry aged cuts (the ones that look brown) when you get to choose your own steak. The white paper signs with red marker will never leave my mind and my wife still sends me to pick up meat at least once a week.

When Ron Lahody decided he was going to open a steakhouse, I had some mixed feelings. I was excited because it was going to be another place to go to dinner. I was worried because I know exactly where he is getting his steaks and I knew I could buy them myself and grill them at home (and pay half the price).

After a few months of protest (my own personal cheapness coming out), I finally took my wife for dinner. And I was blown away by something I wasn’t expecting. Don’t get me wrong, the steak was tasty and the salad was too large for a family of four to eat, but the real surprise was the bourbon selection.

I guess I didn’t know Ron Lahody was a bourbon guy. I remember reading his emails from the meat market and him talking about martinis and other drinks like that. I don’t remember a lot about a crazy love for bourbon.

Once you walk into Trust Your Butcher Steakhouse, you’ll see that you have landed at a great place to get a pour of bourbon. The list has a ton of different selections and they aren’t priced as high as you would find in Indianapolis (still high for the Muncie area though). If you set the price aside, you’ll find that you are in the best bourbon bar in Muncie. I don’t think there is a lot of competition, but it still makes Muncie no longer a bourbon desert.

Outside of Trust Your Butcher, you might be able to find some bourbon at the Clubhouse @ Accutech, Vera Mae’s, 1925 Pub House, and Elm Street Brewing. I don’t know of many other places with a large bourbon selection. One of my hidden gem picks is the Heorot Bar as they sometimes have some killer deals on bourbon and scotch (check out the menu here).

So the next time you are in Muncie and looking for a pour of bourbon, you might want to check out Trust Your Butcher Steakhouse. It’s the best selection of bourbon that Muncie has to offer. I recommend going on a Thursday and picking up their $5 burger special). Once you are done there, make sure to drive out to the Friendly Package in Yorktown to find a few good barrel picks. And if you want to grab a drink, reach out to me and I’ll make it happen!