The Old Fashioned cocktail is a classic libation with a rich history, but did you know that there’s a regional twist to this beloved drink? Enter the Wisconsin Old Fashioned—a variation that has captured the hearts of cocktail enthusiasts in the Badger State. In this blog post, we’ll explore the differences between the traditional Old Fashioned and its Wisconsin counterpart, delving into their unique ingredients, preparation methods, and cultural significance. Get ready to embark on a flavorful journey as we compare and contrast these two delightful variations of the timeless Old Fashioned.

1. The Traditional Old Fashioned: The Old Fashioned cocktail is a revered classic, known for its simplicity and elegance. It typically consists of bourbon or rye whiskey, a sugar cube or simple syrup, Angostura bitters, and a twist of citrus peel. The drink is built by muddling the sugar cube with bitters, adding whiskey, and stirring with ice. The result is a well-balanced cocktail that highlights the rich flavors of the whiskey.
2. The Wisconsin Old Fashioned: The Wisconsin Old Fashioned, often referred to simply as a “Brandy Old Fashioned,” is a beloved variation that has become a cultural staple in the state. In this rendition, brandy takes the place of whiskey as the base spirit. The drink typically incorporates a sugar cube or simple syrup, Angostura bitters, and a splash of soda water. Additionally, it features muddled fruit, most commonly orange slices, maraschino cherries, and sometimes a lemon wedge. The muddled fruit adds a unique sweetness and flavor profile to the cocktail.
3. Flavor Profile and Character: While both versions of the Old Fashioned share some similarities, they differ in terms of flavor profile and character. The traditional Old Fashioned, with its choice of bourbon or rye whiskey, offers a robust and bold taste. The Wisconsin Old Fashioned, on the other hand, featuring brandy and muddled fruit, has a sweeter and fruitier profile that appeals to those with a penchant for a slightly softer and more aromatic experience.
4. Cultural Significance: The Wisconsin Old Fashioned has deep cultural roots in the state’s drinking traditions. It is considered a symbol of Wisconsin’s supper club culture—a cherished tradition where friends and families gather for hearty meals and drinks. The cocktail is often enjoyed as a pre-dinner libation, setting the stage for a leisurely and convivial dining experience. Its popularity in Wisconsin showcases the state’s unique take on a beloved classic.
5. Garnish and Presentation: Another notable distinction between the two variations lies in their garnish and presentation. While the traditional Old Fashioned often opts for a simple twist of citrus peel, the Wisconsin Old Fashioned showcases its muddled fruit as a key garnish. The orange slices, maraschino cherries, and lemon wedge add a vibrant pop of color to the drink, making it visually appealing and inviting.
6. Regional Preferences and Variations: In Wisconsin, where the Wisconsin Old Fashioned reigns supreme, there are additional variations based on personal preferences. Some individuals prefer their Wisconsin Old Fashioned “sweet” with extra simple syrup, while others opt for a “sour” version with a splash of sour mix. It’s not uncommon to find variations that incorporate different fruit combinations, such as substituting orange slices with a mix of oranges and cherries. The beauty of the Wisconsin Old Fashioned lies in its adaptability to individual tastes.

Conclusion: The Old Fashioned and the Wisconsin Old Fashioned are two distinct variations of a timeless classic. While the traditional Old Fashioned focuses on the robust flavors of bourbon or rye whiskey, the Wisconsin Old Fashioned showcases the sweeter and fruitier nuances of brandy and muddled fruit. Both versions offer a delightful sipping experience, each with its own cultural significance and regional preferences. Whether you opt for the classic elegance or the vibrant flavors of the Wisconsin twist, raise your glass and enjoy the timeless allure of the Old Fashioned in all its wonderful variations. Cheers to the art of crafting unforgettable cocktails!